Home
>
Articles
>
By-Law Banning Pets in Strata Building Invalidated by Order of Court of Appeal Supreme Court of New South Wales
By-Law Banning Pets in Strata Building Invalidated by Order of Court of Appeal Supreme Court of New South Wales
13/01/2021
Many people live in buildings which are subject to Strata Schemes. Those buildings consist of varying sizes from a two Lot strata scheme to townhouses in a Strata Scheme and small and large apartment complexes. Various Owners own a Lot within the Strata Scheme. The Lot is defined by reference to the Strata Plan and the laws applying to Strata Schemes. All parts which are not part of the Lot are common property owned by the Owners Corporation. The Owners Corporation consist of all the Lot owners.
The Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 and prior Acts set out the basis of making rules by way of by-laws. By-laws regulate the conduct of Lot owners and occupiers whilst on the common property or inside their own Lots.
There are issues as to the extent that one can make a by-law and separately the Owners Corporation do not have unfettered authority to make any by-laws or any decisions that they wish to make.
The powers given to the Owners Corporation must be exercised properly within the power. We refer to our article on fraud on the minority in which we give some advice in relation to this aspect.
In the recent case decided in October 2020 the Supreme Court of New South Wales was considering a decision of the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) and a decision of the Appeal Panel of NCAT given on 27 May 2020.
The Owners Corporation is the owner of the property known as The Horizon Apartments in Darlinghurst. The Horizon building has approximately 340 Lots in a high rise building.
When the building was newly being constructed it was registered as a Strata Scheme. The original By-laws dealt with many issues including a by-law which had a blanket ban on pets or animals on the common property or any Lot and the effect of it was to prohibit Lot owners (other than those with a disability requiring an assistance animal) keeping an animal or permitting an animal to be on a Lot. This included animals which had no material impact on any other Lot or the Common Property.
This by-law was challenged by the Lot owners of one Lot who wished to keep a miniature schnauzer as a pet.
On 21 November 2019 Senior Member GK Burdon SC sitting at NCAT upheld the applicant’s claim and declared the by-law invalid as Section 139(1) of the Strata Schemes Management Act provided that “a by-law must not be harsh, unconscionable or oppressive”.
The Owners Corporation appeal to the Appeal Panel of NCAT which set aside the orders of the Senior Member.
Thereafter the Owners Corporation appealed to the Court of Appeal Supreme Court of New South Wales.
The Court of Appeal heard the matter on 23 September 2020 and gave a decision 12 October 2020. The Court of Appeal held the by-law was invalid.
The terms of the by-law were as follows:
“An owner or occupier of a Lot must not keep or permit any animal on a Lot or on the common property.”
This is a common form of a by-law dictating owners or occupiers must not keep or permit animals on a Lot or on the common property.
The Lot owner submitted that the by-law breached Section 139(1) of the Strata Schemes Management Act as it was harsh, unconscionable or oppressive and therefore should be found invalid.
The Owners Corporation submitted that this was an original by-law in place since the scheme was created and argued the Lot owner should take no issue with a by-law which she knew about and voluntarily accepted by purchasing a Lot in the apartments. The Court did not accept that any such limitation existed, or that original by-laws were immune to challenge. What any Lot owner did or did not know about any existing by-law is not relevant to whether the by-law is harsh, unconscionable or oppressive.
The Owners Corporation also attempted to argue the by-law was necessary as a matter of convenience to ensure there was not a flood of applications seeking to keep pets, all requiring individual determination. The Court did not accept this. Convenience for the Owners Corporation would not justify a harsh, unconscionable or oppressive by-law.
Additionally the Court has the power to invalidate a by-law made beyond the power of the Owners Corporation. The Strata Schemes Management Act confers a by-law making power on the Owners Corporation, but this is not unconstrained and should only be exercised for proper purposes, e.g. for the benefit of all Lot owners. The Court held at [64] that “there is no sound reason to construe a by-law making power broadly so as to permit a by-law which limits the choice of all Lot owners in the use and enjoyment of their Lots, without conferring any material benefit on those who would not have exercised the right if available.” In short by-laws should not limit the activities of Lot owners to prevent disruption to others. If no disruption would be caused there is no basis for limiting lawful activities.
The by-law was therefore held to be invalid as it was harsh, unconscionable or oppressive and because it was made beyond the statutory by-law making power of the Owners Corporation.
The decision has ramifications for many Strata Schemes which has an overriding by-law banning pets. It is likely that such a by-law will be found invalid for similar reasons as in the above case.
On the other hand by-laws which require consent of the Owners Corporation to keep pets are less likely to be found to be invalid. The issue that arises is whether such a by-law is arguably in the best interest of Lot owners and this will depend on the factual circumstances relating to the Strata Scheme.
Watson & Watson are lawyers experienced in all aspects of Strata disputes, rights and obligations of the Owners Corporation and the various Lot owners. Please contact Watson & Watson by contacting Richard Watson or his Personal Assistant Shereen DaGloria for advice in relation to any issues that arise in relation to the Owners Corporation of which you are a Lot owner or on the Strata Committee or on behalf of the Owners Corporation.
This is only a preliminary view and is not to be taken as legal advice without first contacting Watson & Watson Solicitors on 9221 6011.
-
06/01/2021
For many years there have been strata laws which will allow buildings to be subdivided so that within the same building separate lots can be separately owned. A strata complex consists of various lots which are specified on a Strata Plan. There is also common property which is property which does not form part of any particular lot. There are many disputes in relation to what is common property and what other rights and obligations of each lot owner and also the Owners Corporation.
Read more...
-
18/03/2020
Watson & Watson were approached by the Owners of an apartment in a Harbour front Strata Apartment Complex consisting of six units. There is one unit on each floor and each unit faces the Harbour.
Read more...
-
05/03/2020
Often we receive enquiries from Lot Owners where it appears that the Owners Corporation are taking a very hard line against a particular Lot Owner which is inconsistent with the approach adopted by the Owners Corporation generally throughout the strata building.
Read more...
-
10/02/2020
Our advice to clients last year to avoid commencing damages claims in the Tribunal for breach of duty by Owners Corporations has been shown to be wise, with a further Decision of the Appeal Panel on 15 January 2020, following on from the Decision in October 2019 that we reported in our article published earlier this month.
Read more...
-
04/02/2020
In a decision late last year, a Senior Member of the Tribunal made orders declaring a by-law harsh, unconscionable and oppressive, and ordering the Owners Corporation to remove it from the date of registration.
The by-law excluded pets, and had its application to “Angus”, a 13-year-old miniature schnauzer that the Owners of a Lot had acquired as a pet nine years before they bought into the scheme.
Read more...
-
15/01/2020
Strata buildings are subject to the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (“SSM Act 2015”) and the Strata Schemes Development Act (“Development Act”).
Read more...
-
17/12/2019
The Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) is a Tribunal which deals with different types of applications, referred to it by various legislation. Cases which are brought before the Tribunal are subject to the provisions of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NCAT Act) and the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014 (NCAT Rules). As with most claims that are heard, there are time limits in which you can bring a claim. There are many statutes which specify limitation periods.
Read more...
-
18/11/2019
The general rule relating to disputes is that each party should be heard in relation to a dispute before any Orders are made. However where there is an urgent need for an Order against a person or entity in the absence of that person, a Court or Tribunal may have power to make such order.
Read more...
-
04/09/2019
The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (“NCAT”) has jurisdiction and functions as may be confirmed by the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act (the NCAT Act). The jurisdiction of NCAT is wide and varied. However one needs to find the authority for NCAT to deal with the matter in a particular Act.
Read more...
-
09/04/2019
In 2016 the legislation in relation to Strata Schemes changed. At that time the new strata statute in NSW came into force, which was the Strata Schemes Management Act, 2016.
Read more...
-
14/11/2018
In New South Wales the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (SSMA 2015) sets out the framework for resolving strata disputes. It provides that parties to disputes can lodge applications to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) to resolve those disputes.
Read more...
-
07/11/2018
On 30 November 2016 the new strata schemes regime came into operation in New South Wales. This was set out in the Strata Schemes Management Act, 2015.
Read more...
-
16/10/2018
Under the strata schemes legislation in New South Wales, the Owners Corporation can apply to the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal for Orders that a lot owner provides access so the Owners Corporation can carry out work.
Read more...
-
07/09/2018
It is often the case that developers build multi unit apartment blocks and then the purchasers discover that the building work is defective. The usual remedy that purchasers have to recover the cost of rectification of the defects is to sue the builder who carried out defective work.
Read more...
-
30/08/2018
The Strata Schemes Management Act 1996 was the NSW legislation which applied to Strata Schemes up until November 2015. That legislation under section 65A provided that if a lot owner wanted to add to or alter the common property, the lot owner could only do so if a Special Resolution had first been passed at a General Meeting of the Owners Corporation that authorised that work.
Read more...
-
15/08/2018
Often lot owners wish to change or renovate their units which generally involves some connection and changes to the common property.
Read more...
-
10/08/2018
The Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (SSM Act 2015) has come into force which includes Part 7 which relates to by-laws. In essence the by-laws set out the rules applicable to the owners of various lots and the Owners Corporation and others in a Strata Scheme.
Read more...
-
09/08/2018
By-laws are fundamental to the operation, the rights and obligations of the Owners Corporation, lot owners, occupiers and others for the good management of the Strata building.
Read more...
-
06/08/2018
Sometimes by-laws are proposed and/or passed due to a difficult situation that arises. They can sometimes be proposed and/or passed without careful consideration of the overall and collateral effect.
Read more...
-
01/08/2018
The Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (SSM Act 2015) has introduced a requirement that the Owners Corporation prepare and implement a plan of anticipated major expenses to be met from the Capital Works Fund for a period of 10 years.
Read more...
-
06/04/2018
We refer to our article 1 December 2015 relating to the appointment of a Compulsory Strata Manager to exercise the functions of the Owners Corporation such as when an Application is made to the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) by a lot owner(s) when the lot owner(s) is of the view that the Owners Corporation is not functioning properly.
Read more...
-
03/04/2018
Unfortunately there are thousands of cases involving Lot Owners in disputes with the Owners Corporation as to the obligations of the Owners Corporation. One of the areas of great dispute is the loss to Lot Owners due to the Owners Corporation’s failure to properly maintain the property.
Read more...
-
27/03/2018
The Owners Corporation raises money to undertaken their obligations which include for example, the maintenance of the common property (namely all property other than the individual Lots).
Read more...
-
23/02/2018
The Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (SSM Act 2015) has now come into effect and there are various cases dealing with the operation of that Act.
Read more...
-
09/02/2018
One would have thought that the rules relating to costs would be simple. Unfortunately they are not. Each commentary that we have reviewed has dealt with costs without consideration of the whole of the provisions relating to costs. Assumptions have been made which do not always apply.
Read more...
-
20/01/2018
When one buys a unit, townhouse or villa in New South Wales, one usually acquires an interest in a Strata Scheme. Strata Scheme lots are covered by Strata Scheme Management legislation such as the Strata Schemes Management Act, 2015 (SSM Act 2015) in New South Wales.
Read more...
-
08/01/2018
From December 2016 there has been a change to the strata laws since the introduction of the Strata Schemes Development Act 2015 (SSD Act). This Act refers to the obligations and processes that apply in relation to strata renewal process, by way of collective sale or redevelopment of the strata.
Read more...
-
19/12/2017
From 30 November 2016 there has been a change in the strata law with the introduction of the Strata Schemes Development Act 2015. This act refers to the obligations and processes that apply in relation to strata renewal process, by way of collective sale or redevelopment of the strata.
Read more...
-
19/09/2017
In a recent case decide by the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) in August 2017 NCAT ordered that the Owners Corporation pay the Lot Owner $55,943.24 due to the failure of the Owners Corporation to properly maintain the common property. This was essentially to cover loss of rent suffered by the Lot Owner.
Read more...
-
07/09/2017
Watson & Watson commercial litigation Solicitors, in particular in relation to building defects, building disputes and building issues are experienced and can provide you with cost efficient advice.
Read more...
-
17/08/2017
Every person who has purchased a unit which has been renovated will have an issue as to who is responsible for any losses, damages etc if something goes wrong with the building works.
Read more...
-
15/08/2017
There are many thousands of home units in Sydney which are within the Strata Scheme. Many of the units are relatively new and there are many older style blocks of units. Strata title units have been in existence for more than 50 years.
Read more...
-
12/07/2017
A recent Supreme Court case highlighted a difficulty for Owners Corporations which bring cases against Builders or other parties. The recent case of the Owners Corporation – Strata Plan 64415 v Serman decided that it was possible that a Defendant to a claim bought by an Owners Corporation may obtain in the appropriate circumstances, an order that the Owners Corporation provide security for costs as a precondition of the Owners Corporation proceeding with its case.
Read more...
-
05/07/2017
Generally, the Owner’s Corporation enforces breaches of the by-laws by an individual lot owner in the strata scheme.
Read more...
-
09/06/2017
The model rules on keeping of pets provide as a first option that it is possible for owners or occupiers of lots to keep animals so long as those owners or occupiers give written notice of their intention and they make sure the animal stays within the lot, is supervised on common property and the owner cleans up common property areas if required.
Read more...
-
06/06/2017
In late 2016, the NSW government introduced new laws regarding smoking. The laws allow a strata scheme to adopt new “model rules” covering these topics.
Read more...
-
17/03/2017
Recent Amendments from December 2016 makes it easier for Lot Owners to recover losses due to failure by Owners Corporation.
Read more...
-
21/02/2017
There have been very extensive changes to the Strata Laws as from 30 November 2016.
Read more...
-
28/07/2016
In the decision of Thadani the Owners Corporation Strata Plan 46619 [2015] NSW CATCD 153 Senior Member Meadows ordered that the Respondent the Strata Owners Corporation pay a pecuniary penalty in the amount $5,000. The Owners Corporation had failed to comply with an Order made against it to correct a Building Defect to the common property causing damage to an individual lot.
Read more...
-
21/07/2016
The rules and legislation governing strata law provide that in some cases, a Lot Owner can request that a Compulsory Strata Manager be appointed to a Strata Scheme. In order to have such a manager appointed, one must make an application to the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (“NCAT”).
Read more...
-
14/07/2016
Often we at Watson & Watson experienced Strata Lawyers receive enquiries from Owners within a Strata Plan, the Owners Corporation or Strata Managers as to what can be done when the Owners Corporation is not functioning properly.
Read more...
-
07/07/2016
Owners of Lots in Strata Schemes often want to carry out work on their unit or townhouse. This article concerns the approvals required to carry out the work.
Read more...
-
21/12/2015
Strata laws were first introduced in New South Wales in the 1960s and now most units and townhouses or other community accommodation are Strata and are subject to the Strata Schemes Management Act 1996 as is amended from time to time.
Read more...
-
14/12/2015
Liability not limited to cost of repair Lot Owner may have claim for losses.
Read more...
-
01/12/2015
Right to appoint Strata Manager in place of the Executive Committee and Owners Corporation - Section 162 Strata Schemes Management Act 1996.
Read more...
-
10/08/2015
Attached is a letter from the Department of Fair Trading to the Principal, Richard Watson seeking his views on the drafting of the Strata Schemes Development Bill 2015 and Strata Schemes Management Bill 2015 before they are introduced into the NSW Parliament. If you wish to make any Submissions in respect of these Bills, you should send your Submissons to policy@finance.nsw.gov.au by 12 August 2015.”
Read more...
-
01/11/2010
Watson & Watson strata lawyers can help the owners of strata lots and Owners Corporations and executive committees resolve disputes involving defective building works by the original developer or other building contractors including disputes with builders, subcontractors, consultants, architects and engineers where the building work is faulty either by way of faulty work or faulty material or inappropriate design and other related issues.
Read more...
-
03/10/2010
Watson & Watson’s building and construction lawyers have many years of experience resolving building disputes, including those relating to work undertaken within a Strata Scheme.
Read more...
-
01/10/2010
When you buy strata title property you automatically become a member of the Owners Corporation (or the Body Corporate).
Read more...
-
30/09/2010
“Some small light has been shed on the whether legal costs can be included in a suit by an owners corporation for strata dues.” “An owners corporation should include in any action for contributions an amount for costs…and should be ready ay any contested hearing to provide an estimate of its costs…”
Read more...
-
20/09/2010
A Section 109 Certificate is a certificate issued by the Owners Corporation of a Strata Scheme, containing detailed financial information about a specific ‘lot’, and information about the management of the scheme.
Read more...
-
01/09/2010
Watson & Watson have lawyers experienced with strata titles and other multi ownership of property such as company titles with over 20 years experience handling strata matters, ranging from those that arise within residential strata schemes, commercial strata schemes and industrial strata schemes and company title ownership. Watson & Watson act for Owners Corporations, Strata Managers, strata title property owners, and developers of strata properties.
Read more...